Over the years I’ve acquired many magazine holders for my growing collection of genealogy journals and periodicals. The situation looked something like this:

Part of the journal collection in a variety of holders.
Not bad, but I was always running out of room in the boxes. Recently, I bought some loose single copies of the Rhode Island Genealogical Register, to fill in some gaps in my collection of the bound volumes. I knew I didn’t want to throw the loose volumes in a box. Then I would have to pull out all 20 of them to find one issue.
The idea of grouping my issues by year came from this 1923 issue of The New England Historic Genealogical Register that I acquired a few years ago at a book giveaway table at a Rhode Island Genealogical Society meeting.

The New England Historic Genealogical Register, all issues for 1923.
I was fascinated with the modest efficiency of what is, essentially, a bookcover. It serves as a faux binding for an index volume and four issues. Because it’s labelled, you can more easily find the issue you are looking for than in those boxes.
Making the journal covers
I gathered up some paper, tape, cardboard and my trusty P-touch label maker.

Shelf liner paper, various large postcards and other light cardboard I found around the house, and some shopping bags.
I got some drawer lining paper with a coupon at Michael’s. It was conveniently cut in sheets that were a perfect size for smaller journals. I also tried some shopping bags, but decided in the end they were too thick.

I gathered the journals and put each one in order by year.
It’s like making a bookcover, except you add some light cardboard to the inside cover, one in the front of the first issue and one in the back of the last issue, and tape the bookcover to the cardboard to add structure. NOTHING gets attached to any journal issue. The 2 or 3 issues in the middle of the set are, essentially, loose and could fall out, but it’s surprising how well these hold together.

Folding the top and bottom of the paper sheet according to the size of the journal. Adding the cardboard sheet.

The back cover being slid in place. Note the tape is on the cardboard.

Each pile of 4 issues tends to slide around a bit while you’re working on them. That’s actually helpful, making it very easy to position the front and back cover.
I tried to use the shopping bags, but only managed to use them on 2 covers when I decided they were too stiff and bulky. I decided wrapping paper would be better, but good quality wrapping paper, like the kind you get at the Container Store. Fortunately I had hit their Dec 26 sale pretty hard last year, so I looked over my supply. Wow, Christmas-y. Oh well. I like Christmas.
For the larger journals, I cut up wrapping paper. It worked very well. And it was cheerful looking.

The Christmas paper from the Container Store made a nice cover.
When I was done, the journals were all separated by year and easy to find.

The journal covers in place. They take up a lot less room than the boxes, and the issues don’t slouch like they do in the boxes.
Making it work
- This lends itself to using what’s around, although my idea about shopping bags didn’t work.
- Instead of drawer liners I think another time I would go with all wrapping paper, and, with more planning, not Christmas paper. For people who save wrapping paper from use to use, this could work well. But it would have to be heavy.
- Rolls of shelf lining paper might work or, of course, the ubiquitous brown paper bag, or brown wrapping. Almost any large sheet of paper is a possibility.
- Another time I might be more careful about matching all issues of something in one paper. Although in subsequent years it’s bound to get mixed up anyway.
- For those worried about the loose issues inside, an elastic from top to bottom would protect them more in the case of an earthquake or a broken shelf, and wouldn’t show.
- For the cardboard inside the front and back cover, large postcard ads worked well, or shirt cardboard, old folders, even large index cards for the smaller journals. It need not be absolutely as large as the cover.
- Another time, I would make labels on the computer. It took too long with the P-touch.

The newly faux-bound journals are looking good.
I did about 30 volumes; the rest are elsewhere in the bookcase. I’m keeping some holders around for new issues. I guess I would have to do this once a year.
The post you are reading is located at: http://onerhodeislandfamily.com/2015/07/21/journal-collection/
Clever, clever! I’m staring at my journals right now, wondering if I’m up to doing this… I’ve never tried to do anything the least scrapbook’ish, but this does look very do-able. Merci for the great ideas – and the several more in the comments!
Good luck Celia! Keep the papers large – deep pockets at the front and back work best. Just last night I had to look for an issue and they were all lined up by volume – made it so easy. I am no scrapbooker either.
These are great ideas. All of them are assuming you have room on your shelves. Living in a mobile home has its drawbacks!
Also vinyl non pasted wallpaper works well too. You can often find rolls re cheap in the clearence bin at paint and wallpaper stores. It doesn’t fade and holds up to damp cloth cleaning.
Debbie I was totally wondering about that. But I didn’t know if unpasted wallpaper was around anymore. If it could be found cheap, I think it would be the best idea of all.
One neat trick I have found to bind up all those small pamphlets is to stack your pile the height you like, cut a piece if card stock the height, length and width to make the spine of the book. Now cut pieces of crochet threads 6 inches longer than the height of the book. Cut enough for each pamphlet. Now place one in the middle of each booklet, leaving extra length evenly top and bottom. Now re stack add spine and tap or glue threads to spine. And cover like you recommend. This way they stay together, but if you ever need to take it apart you are not damaging its integrity. I hope I explained it ok.
I think I know what you’re saying, Debbie. A thread runs through the center fold of each pamphlet. Thanks!
Love this! Now i know what to do with all those “other” sheets of scrapbook paper I can’t ever seem to use up! Brilliant!
Jenny, I think your worlds are colliding!
My National Geographic magaizines are in purchased slip cases. Other magazines, programs, pamphlets, etc., are in three-ring binders; my local Kinkos/Fed Ex store will drill the three holes for a smal fee. Then I can make labels for the spine and front cover of the binder.
I like that Howland. Thanks for the idea.